mirror of
https://github.com/opsxcq/mirror-textfiles.com.git
synced 2025-08-09 20:26:33 +02:00
555 lines
28 KiB
HTML
555 lines
28 KiB
HTML
<HTML>
|
|
<TITLE>T E X T F I L E S</TITLE>
|
|
<BODY BGCOLOR="#000000" VLINK="#00DD00" LINK="#00FF00" TEXT="#00FF00">
|
|
<P>
|
|
<B>CLEARING OF WORDS AT DEFCON</B>
|
|
<P>
|
|
I'm a firm believer that if you make addendums or additions/corrections
|
|
to an article, you leave the original article entirely intact, and put
|
|
a clarification statement before the original article. I find this makes
|
|
it much easier both to separate the changes that would normally slip into
|
|
a later revision of a document sight unseen, and also lets you see,
|
|
together, both the progression of thought and the original jumping-off
|
|
point.
|
|
<P>
|
|
Roughly 100 people have read the article at my site by this point. I
|
|
know that it was copied and posted to a number of mailing lists, and
|
|
that means the number of viewers is probably a bit more. Most importantly,
|
|
the article filtered to the DEFCON organizers/staff mailing list.
|
|
Within about a day of my article going up on this page, I recieved
|
|
various communications from a number of DEFCON Staff (I still hate the
|
|
term "goon" and believe strongly it is both misleading and part of the
|
|
problem) with opinions about the article.
|
|
I've had the opportunity to discuss the events of July 13, 2001 with them.
|
|
The conversation has also, in a few cases, expanded to the idea of DEFCON
|
|
and being a Goon in general, as well as helping work through the lingering
|
|
issues that I think my article raises. Some of these issues, I believe,
|
|
linger in the mind of many DEFCON attendees, and are either forgotten
|
|
until the next year, or groused in the sort of quiet, non-threatening
|
|
way that people train themselves to do to avoid "trouble".
|
|
<P>
|
|
However, that's obviously not what I did; I typed out my thoughts and
|
|
put them out on my site, and now I'd like to to tell you about what I've
|
|
learned from the "Other Side", the folks who help run DEFCON every year.
|
|
<P>
|
|
(You are doing yourself a major disservice if you do not first read
|
|
<A HREF="http://www.textfiles.com/thoughts/gun.html#original">the
|
|
original article as it appeared</A> on this page.)
|
|
<P>
|
|
I can defuse some of the issues by clarifying what I was trying to say
|
|
in my writing.
|
|
<P>
|
|
<BLOCKQUOTE>
|
|
<I>Coming to the wild, wooly, and enjoyable DEFCON this year, I idly
|
|
watched some pamphlets get distributed with the same sort of hazy
|
|
indifference that many attendees might show towards the usual complaints
|
|
that the event they're attending is sub-par. My neutrality towards
|
|
the complaints were quickly sharpened to a full awareness when I
|
|
was intensely (by my standards) interrogated by armed guards working
|
|
in the capacity of DEFCON staff, accompanied by a number of
|
|
red-shirted goons angry about the pamphlet. Defusing the situation
|
|
as best I could from my side, the guards moved on to other suspects,
|
|
and I was left with the cold sweat of a person who has felt the
|
|
crosshairs of an overactive investigator pass over him and move
|
|
elsewhere.</I>
|
|
<P>
|
|
<I>I came away from this experience with a sour taste in my mouth,
|
|
and I felt this was an extraordinary thing to bring into such a
|
|
naturally volatile conference, especially over a pamphlet.
|
|
To prove my point about the positive aspects of airing out words
|
|
instead of hiding them away, I review the issues raised by the pamphlet
|
|
(as best I can) and leave them sitting there, ugly and naked, much
|
|
as I've heard them recounted to me in the past.
|
|
</I>
|
|
</BLOCKQUOTE>
|
|
<P>
|
|
How well I achieved this goal is up to the individual reader, but
|
|
I recieved feedback ranging from "thought-provoking" and "interesting"
|
|
to "long-winded", "one-sided" and "fiction".
|
|
<P>
|
|
It's not fiction; it's what I saw and felt. It was definitely
|
|
one-sided: the feelings of the attendees who were in the scene. I
|
|
ran the article by them before putting it up on my site, because
|
|
I wanted to make sure I was as accurate as possible.
|
|
<P>
|
|
That said, several of the criticisms I recieved were very valid.
|
|
The article contained a number of factual errors which have been
|
|
brought to my attention. Most of these errors center around the
|
|
specific structure, responsibilities, and hierarchy of the DEFCON
|
|
Staff. I would be doing a disservice to attempt to accurately
|
|
describe the whole team, other than to say that some are paid
|
|
(for repetitive jobs such as registration and inspecting badges)
|
|
some are volunteers (goons), and some are in an administrative
|
|
capacity and technically recieve money although not as employees
|
|
(such as Jeff). Most glaringly, the DEFCON staff also includes (in a
|
|
manner of speaking) the Alexis Park Security Team, which is a separate
|
|
organization run by the hotel itself. These are the only individuals
|
|
who were carrying a gun in a holster during DEFCON. No goon wielded
|
|
a gun, and DEFCON did not hire armed guards; they merely used the
|
|
services of already present armed guards. In the case of my experience,
|
|
this is almost academic, because regardless of who the guard was
|
|
beholden to, I was interrogated on the spot and I did feel threatened,
|
|
but he was not put in place specifically by the DEFCON organizers.
|
|
<P>
|
|
Therefore, saying that this was the first year that DEFCON had armed
|
|
guards was wrong. It would be much more accurate to say that this was
|
|
the first year that I became aware of an armed presence moving through
|
|
the convention, and once I knew to look for holsters, I saw them an
|
|
awful lot. This bothered me because armed authority figures means
|
|
the potential for someone to get shot, and I don't like to see
|
|
people get shot.
|
|
<P>
|
|
There is some confusion, even among the DEFCON staff that contacted me,
|
|
as to how much of the use of the Security staff was the doing of the Alexis
|
|
Park and how much of it was the actual DEFCON staff. The use of the guards
|
|
was certainly effective in terms of sniffing out suspects and generally
|
|
getting "the job done". The question that lingers is whether this was
|
|
a course of action that needed to be taken to get "the job done". And
|
|
now we get to the meat of the issue.
|
|
<P>
|
|
DEFCON is obviously an entirely different experience for the Goons and
|
|
the Security/Hired Staff than it is for the attendees. There's a strong
|
|
hint of that in the promotional materials and in the attitudes of the
|
|
staff if you talk with them, but it's not explicitly written down anywhere:
|
|
The near misses of violence or medical emergencies they contend with,
|
|
the harassment many recieve, the strange and taxing situations they
|
|
will find themselves in, in a moment's notice. I had the number of 5,200
|
|
attendees for DEFCON 9 mentioned to me; if this is the case, then it's
|
|
hundreds of people per Goon on duty, and that can be a tinderbox and
|
|
an endless cascade of difficult momentary decisions to be made.
|
|
And what it tends to end up with is a misunderstanding as to why the
|
|
Goons are taking an action, and towards what purpose.
|
|
<P>
|
|
An example: I was one of several dozen witnesses who watched a young
|
|
male attendee get ordered out of one of the pools because he was swimming
|
|
naked in it as part of the Defcon Scavenger Hunt. He was thrown a towel,
|
|
made to climb out of the pool, and talked to for a number of minutes.
|
|
To myself (and a number of others, I would like to think) this scene
|
|
made no sense; he didn't seem intoxicated or under the influence of
|
|
drugs (he was doing an excellent butterfly stroke) and he "wasn't
|
|
hurtin' nobody". And yet here he was being hauled out like he'd just
|
|
broken a neighbor's window with his baseball. It made no sense to me.
|
|
<P>
|
|
It has now been explained to me that the Alexis Park has a strict policy
|
|
and demand under the laws of Nevada against public nudity. Apparently
|
|
this is enough of an issue that they have to step in quickly in any
|
|
case where public nudity occurs on hotel grounds. This has been
|
|
indicated to me as a strict state law issue, on the same level as
|
|
the fire laws (rules governing the occupancy limits of a room). The
|
|
ability of the fire marshalls in Las Vegas to shut down an entire
|
|
convention/meeting has been made clear to me by other people than
|
|
just DEFCON, so I can personally vouch for it. Laws are funny things.
|
|
<P>
|
|
How are we supposed to know about all these unusual legal situations?
|
|
<P>
|
|
Well, yes, we could go to the laws of Nevada and look all of them up.
|
|
But then again, that would also rule out underage drinking, violation
|
|
of copyright laws, and felony computer intrusion, all of which also
|
|
occurred. So that's not very helpful to know what's a no-no and will
|
|
cause the staff, security, or goons to get involved.
|
|
<P>
|
|
The staff knows what the real big problems are, and why they're the
|
|
big problems. They go out of their way on the website to give you
|
|
reading lists, file mirrors, FTP sites, and links to caravans and
|
|
gun shoots, but there's surprisingly little on what the actual current
|
|
structure of staff is, what the hotel has very strict policies against,
|
|
and what all of the staff's responsibilities/priorities are. This
|
|
is just the thing to add to the website.
|
|
<P>
|
|
It is my belief that many, many misunderstandings, hard feelings,
|
|
rumors, speculation, lies and the usual poison could be avoided if
|
|
DEFCON sat down and wrote the following:
|
|
<P>
|
|
<BLOCKQUOTE>
|
|
<I>
|
|
An Accounting, as best as they could, about all the major
|
|
events that were encountered during the cons just past, what actions
|
|
were taken, what the opinion of the DEFCON staff was, and what the
|
|
resolution ultimately was for the conflict.
|
|
<P>
|
|
A clearer disclosure of the role of Alexis Park Security in the
|
|
entire running of DEFCON, and when they are generally called
|
|
upon to intervene in the convention.
|
|
<P>
|
|
And, as mentioned above, a more explicit listing of some of the
|
|
more quirky aspects of the Alexis Park and Las Vegas rules and
|
|
how people might find themselves in conflict with them without
|
|
knowing it. Framed as a way of saying the staff is NOT insane
|
|
and NOT micromanaging the convention, it will help put together
|
|
a clearer face on the people doing all the hard work of
|
|
keeping the convention running smoothly.
|
|
</I>
|
|
</BLOCKQUOTE>
|
|
<P>
|
|
The second part of the article ensnares me into a number of growing
|
|
conflicts and stale debates I don't honestly want to be a direct part of.
|
|
<P>
|
|
Regarding my statements about HOPE versus DEFCON, to be honest, I will
|
|
continue to attend both, and both sides dragging each other into a
|
|
war of words and claims helps neither of them. It's also not my war,
|
|
and I couldn't fight it if I wanted to. May the best man win, and I
|
|
hope it's both of you.
|
|
<P>
|
|
The money made or not made at DEFCON is not my direct concern; I
|
|
certainly like to buy t-shirts and swag at these events, and as I've
|
|
always been a speaker at DEFCON, I've never actually paid the admission
|
|
fee, so its debatable expensiveness is me talking theories and not
|
|
facts. (It's obviously up in the air whether I will be able to speak
|
|
next year). If massive money is made, lost, stolen or earned, I
|
|
myself got my money's worth.
|
|
<P>
|
|
But Jeff should be aware of the amount of questions about the money
|
|
part of DEFCON. They've always hovered around it like a stink as long as
|
|
I've paid attention, and will continue to. He tends to answer these
|
|
criticisms with one or two line responses that have the theme of
|
|
"This con takes a lot of money to put on, and you get your money's
|
|
worth." This is his battle, not mine, and he knows how and whether
|
|
to respond to it.
|
|
<P>
|
|
Black Hat is another issue altogether. I've never attended Black
|
|
Hat, I know I can't afford it, I doubt I could convince my employer
|
|
I need to go there, and I don't think speeches about BBS History
|
|
will be welcomed with open arms to a security symposium. It's
|
|
another distant issue as regards me.
|
|
<P>
|
|
So why would I ever have brought all these thorny, sticky issues up?
|
|
Mostly to prove a point, I suppose; that if the flyer's questions,
|
|
no matter how crudely expressed, were in some way supressed or
|
|
censored, then the natual response by the kind of person who attends
|
|
DEFCON would be to consider the issues raised by the pamphlet.
|
|
And the issue is: Is DEFCON Exploiting Hackers and hacking culture's
|
|
natural openness for personal monetary gain? Is DEFCON part of the
|
|
problem instead of the solution?
|
|
<P>
|
|
But ultimately, I'm not going to answer that question. The Goons
|
|
certainly don't think this is the case. Jeff doesn't seem to think
|
|
this is the case. And the attendees.... well, someone should ask
|
|
them.
|
|
<P>
|
|
So to end what has been an overly long rebuttal/clarification that
|
|
has extended past the original length of the article it is discussing,
|
|
I hope I've made it clearer why I wrote my article in the first place
|
|
and that my feelings were genuine and true, if not granted all
|
|
the perspective of the DEFCON staff. One member of the DEFCON
|
|
staff wanted me to tell you to feel free to ask the goons at DEFCON
|
|
why they're doing something or not doing something, to seek them
|
|
out and ask them for information or clarification if they don't
|
|
understand why a choice was made or an action was taken. I can't
|
|
voice for how this will work out in a real life situation.
|
|
<P>
|
|
And speaking of real life, that's what this whole thing was about.
|
|
Theoretical vs. Practical. Concepts of freedom or keeping the
|
|
peace vs. percieved threats and angry words spoken in the heat of
|
|
fear or indignity.
|
|
To drag out one of the other famous statements about freedom, also
|
|
from Justice Oliver Wendell Holmes: "The right to swing your fist
|
|
ends at the tip of my nose." When words become actions, that's when
|
|
defense is unquestionably justified. When words are just words, that's
|
|
when the principles of free speech come into play. When there's question
|
|
on any side as to what is speech and what is action... that's where
|
|
the mud comes in, the names are called, and the misunderstandings
|
|
can explode into accusations, interrogations, protests, and
|
|
retaliation.
|
|
<P>
|
|
I don't pretend to have all the answers, or to know what the right thing
|
|
is. I have my principles about feeling secure with one's possessions and
|
|
well-being and I have an awful bad feeling when I see a fight over words.
|
|
I used words to get attention to the situation, and that has now happened.
|
|
I hope that my efforts, in some small part, help everyone, staff and
|
|
attendee, understand where the other side is coming from.
|
|
<P>
|
|
- Jason Scott<BR>
|
|
July 20, 2001
|
|
<P>
|
|
<HR HEIGHT=5>
|
|
<P>
|
|
<A NAME="original">
|
|
|
|
<FONT FACE="Courier New" COLOR="#00FF00" SIZE=+1>
|
|
<B>FEAR OF WORDS AT DEFCON</B>
|
|
<P>
|
|
<I><B>
|
|
The gun knocked against my friend's head as he turned to me. "What is your
|
|
name? Where are you from? Tell me who the person was who did this. You know
|
|
who they are."
|
|
</I></B>
|
|
<P>
|
|
</FONT>
|
|
<FONT FACE="Courier New" COLOR="#00FF00" SIZE=-1>
|
|
You might think I was quoting some cheap detective novel, or maybe describing
|
|
my visit to some oppressive country and what went wrong, but I'm not.
|
|
<P>
|
|
I'm talking about my first day at DEFCON 9.
|
|
<P>
|
|
<A HREF="http://www.defcon.org">DEFCON</A>,
|
|
if you've not heard of it, is billed as the largest convention of
|
|
hackers and computer people on earth. They gather once a year in Las Vegas,
|
|
Nevada, in what until now has been a series of hotels, each one burnt out
|
|
by the surrounding vandalism and mischief of the legions of miscreants that
|
|
accompany the experience. In the last few years, it has stayed at the
|
|
<A HREF="http://www.alexispark.com/">Alexis Park Hotel</A>,
|
|
an off-strip "resort" hotel that has no on-premises
|
|
gambling, and which therefore can allow people aged less than 21 to rent
|
|
hotel rooms and walk around without too much trouble.
|
|
<P>
|
|
<A HREF="http://directory.google.com/Top/Computers/Hacking/Conventions/">"Cons"</A>
|
|
of this sort have been going on for
|
|
<A HREF="http://www.savage.net/public_html/net/cons.html">roughly 10-11 years</A>, and meetings of hackers in public spaces went on for decades before that.
|
|
|
|
I avoided the conventions before 1998 because I had nothing but fear about
|
|
such a stable, easy-to-see target; so many self-professed hackers in one
|
|
place, in a world where people have been brutally mistreated by police for
|
|
merely congregating in shopping malls? This wasn't a place I'd feel safe at.
|
|
<P>
|
|
But DEFCON proved itself to be a different sort of animal; with thousands
|
|
of people in one place, I figured there was safety in numbers. People might
|
|
not like the "mainstream" appeal of DEFCON, but at the time it was what finally
|
|
convinced me to attend. One rent-a-cop harassing 20 people in a hotel room is
|
|
one thing; trying to mistreat thousands of people at once would be another.
|
|
<P>
|
|
And I was right.... sort of.
|
|
<P>
|
|
DEFCON is now so large that it was able to sign a multi-year contract with
|
|
the Alexis Park, ensuring a semi-permanent location. Thanks to the efforts
|
|
of the
|
|
<A HREF="http://www.cultdeadcow.com">Cult of the Dead Cow</A>
|
|
and their release of the
|
|
<A HREF="http://www.theregister.co.uk/content/28/16903.html">Back Orifice</A>
|
|
suite of tools at two DEFCONs, worldwide press has focused on the event as an
|
|
easy lap-up of stories for the next couple of weeks. This means a lot of
|
|
attention, a lot of press, and a lot of focus on the general debauchery that
|
|
takes place at the hotel. Each year, a new group of people come trying to
|
|
outdo the legends of the previous year. And each year someone generally
|
|
does in fact reach a new low or high in various ways: I won't waste space
|
|
recounting the many destructive and inspiring events that have taken place.
|
|
<P>
|
|
But this year, things were a little different.
|
|
<P>
|
|
DEFCON hired armed guards.
|
|
<P>
|
|
Lots of them.
|
|
<P>
|
|
And they put them everywhere.
|
|
<P>
|
|
The purpose of having such a massive armed security force at DEFCON is
|
|
obvious; you can't have 4,500 people in one place, especially with the
|
|
years of examples from when these people last met, without wanting some
|
|
ability to control the crowds. You try and make the best preparation
|
|
you can for any contingency, and there comes a time when a volunteer force
|
|
of friends and associates brought together by word of mouth just doesn't
|
|
seem adequate against an army of free-thinking hacker types. So you make
|
|
a tough choice; you bring in "the professionals".
|
|
<P>
|
|
DEFCON has its own force of volunteer guards, organizers and general
|
|
administrators of the peace. They call them "Goons". The term
|
|
<A HREF="http://www.dictionary.com/cgi-bin/dict.pl?term=goon">Goon</A>
|
|
means, among other things, a thug, and was probably once an ironic
|
|
term used to describe helpful volunteers as some sort of scary force.
|
|
This is similar to calling your loose camaraderie of friends a
|
|
"Secret Ninja Army". You're neither secret, ninjas, or an army; you're
|
|
just a group of people proud to know each other. Unfortunately, the
|
|
"Goon" term just serves to alienate these volunteers from the other
|
|
people at DEFCON. When I use the term "Goon" here, I use it because they
|
|
use it, not because I think that's what they actually are.
|
|
<P>
|
|
There's some <A HREF="http://www.fitshaced.com/4/aa.html">lingering
|
|
questions</A> as to what these professionals can and can't do. In the case
|
|
of DEFCON, they had the full run of the place, deciding who could or
|
|
couldn't enter the convention area, breaking up any "unwanted" activities,
|
|
and generally making themselves known as a position of authority.
|
|
<P>
|
|
But the professionals are, technically, under the control of the people who
|
|
hired them. And they take their cues from their bosses. If the bosses say
|
|
something is unimportant, they will ignore it. If the bosses say that
|
|
something is vital, then it becomes top priority.
|
|
<P>
|
|
On July 13th, a set of pamphlets started showing up in the bar and lobby area
|
|
of the Alexis Park. Entitled "REJECT HACKER EXPLOITATION - FIGHT BACK", this
|
|
single sided one-eighth-page paper gave a list of suggestions and thoughts
|
|
on DEFCON and what it has become. It espoused several general themes: DEFCON
|
|
has become the very corporation it supposedly was created to fight, you
|
|
should turn DEFCON into a scene of Chaos, and you should refuse to follow
|
|
the artificially-imposed rules DEFCON has placed on its attendees.
|
|
<P>
|
|
But don't take my word for it.
|
|
<A HREF="flyer.jpg">Read the Pamphlet Yourself.</A>
|
|
<P>
|
|
The pamphlet is juvenille. It's simplistic. It's badly thought out. But
|
|
it's JUST A PAMPHLET! It's WORDS ON A PAGE.
|
|
<P>
|
|
So because someone distributed a pamphlet with the phrase "Fuck up a Goon",
|
|
the armed security force started hunting people out, interrogating on the
|
|
spot, looking for "the perpetrators", and generally turning the entire
|
|
convention into the scene of a witchhunt.
|
|
<P>
|
|
So it was that I found myself in the bar area of DEFCON being interrogated
|
|
by an armed guard. When he sauntered over to our table and pointed at the
|
|
pamphlets scattered about, he turned and his holstered gun smacked against
|
|
my friend's head. This brought my strict and firmest attention.
|
|
<A HREF="http://vagina.rotten.com/poliz1/poliz5.html">I've seen what
|
|
guns can do to people.</A>
|
|
<P>
|
|
"Are these your pamphlets?" he demanded. No sir, we said. "Did you see who
|
|
put these pamphlets here?" Some guys, we said. "Can you describe them?"
|
|
No, we couldn't.
|
|
<P>
|
|
<I>
|
|
I knew exactly who had dropped those pamphlets here. But even though we
|
|
weren't the closest people in the world, there was no way I was sending an
|
|
armed man against him. This is the sort of choice a person has to make in
|
|
this situation. It's not a "snitch-rat" sort of thing; it's a "decency"
|
|
sort of thing.
|
|
</I>
|
|
<P>
|
|
He walked away, into a back room that I saw was full of other guards like
|
|
himself. My friends and I discussed how unpleasant we felt, and how much
|
|
overreaction was happening.
|
|
<P>
|
|
Then they came out again.
|
|
<P>
|
|
Now it was a couple goons and several armed guards surrounding us. The
|
|
"manager" guard (no obvious gun, wearing a suit, part of the entourage
|
|
nonetheless) walked around out of our sight while the questions came
|
|
again.
|
|
<P>
|
|
The look on the goon's face was pinched, angry. The
|
|
guards asked the questions again, and further ones besides. "Where are
|
|
you all staying? What are your names? Are you staying at this hotel?
|
|
You must tell us WHO THESE PEOPLE ARE."
|
|
<P>
|
|
I glanced nervously down at my knapsack. I'd taken some copies of the
|
|
pamphlet for a souvenier; were they going to <I>search through my
|
|
belongings</I>? Could I stop them if I wanted to? Would they try to
|
|
physically restrain me if I refused or decided to walk away?
|
|
<P>
|
|
<B>I SHOULD NOT HAVE HAD TO CONSIDER THESE THOUGHTS.</B>
|
|
<P>
|
|
This entire situation was a classic out-of-control escalation. Faced
|
|
with nameless person or persons who mentioned violence against them in
|
|
a pamphlet, the goons decided to use any means at their disposal to
|
|
ferret out the responsible parties. Guards brought in to quell potential
|
|
violence or serve as a hardened private police force in the event of a
|
|
riot or major threat to life and limb were now trying to find who
|
|
had printed some words on a paper.
|
|
<P>
|
|
I stood up and immediately introduced myself, engaging them in a conversation
|
|
and revealing that I was just another speaker at the con, someone who was
|
|
harmless and completely on their side. This calmed the situation
|
|
immediately, and I heard the goon say "They're cool." The manager guard
|
|
behind me nodded and turned back to his cell phone, moving the entire
|
|
entourage out into the lobby.
|
|
<P>
|
|
Before leaving, the guard took all the copies of the pamphlet lying around,
|
|
gathering them up into a pile and taking the stack with him. Ostensibly
|
|
they destroyed them all.
|
|
<P>
|
|
The goon was wild-eyed with anger and fear. "I don't want to have one of
|
|
us stabbed with a screwdriver because of this." He went away as well.
|
|
<P>
|
|
Yes, that's right. Someone would actually attempt murder on someone because
|
|
they read on a little piece of paper that the person should be "fucked up".
|
|
This is poor, panicked thinking, the thinking of a person who has no sense
|
|
of context, who sees a single sentence aimed at his archetype, and goes
|
|
temporarily insane.
|
|
<P>
|
|
I specifically heard the guards use the phrase "This is like shouting
|
|
'fire' in a crowded theatre." How learned they are to discuss a quote from
|
|
a 1919 supreme court case! But as better
|
|
<A HREF="http://www.eclipse.net/~mtngoat/fire.htm">covered in other
|
|
forums</A>, this phrase is often misquoted, and in fact may have been
|
|
<A HREF="http://www.krusch.com/real/supreme.html">entirely unnecessary</A>
|
|
in the original case it was part of.
|
|
<P>
|
|
At least the circumstances of the two cases were similar in that a
|
|
pamphlet was involved (the 1919 supreme court case was over an anti-war
|
|
pamphlet, and this was over an anti-DEFCON pamphlet). Of course, the original
|
|
individuals were convincted of conspiracy to violate the Espionage Act
|
|
during wartime. It was said their words represented a
|
|
"<A HREF="http://www.tourolaw.edu/patch/Schenck/">Clear and Present Danger</A>"
|
|
to the country.
|
|
<P>
|
|
So was a pamphlet with a list of destructive things to do at DEFCON a
|
|
"Clear and Present Danger" that could represent a violation of federal
|
|
law by inciting subordination among the nation's military? Well, no.
|
|
It was a somewhat crude anti-DEFCON pamphlet printed on cheap paper that
|
|
got scattered over a hotel lobby in during DEFCON.
|
|
<P>
|
|
You see, this entire situation is especially henious to me because of the
|
|
site I run here. With 30,000+ files of all types, if I actually believed that
|
|
people would be incited to do horrible things because of my files, I'd
|
|
cry myself to sleep each night. That's not why I put these files up;
|
|
I put them up because they represent real and honest history. People typed
|
|
these files for a reason; maybe by putting them all together, we can learn
|
|
more about people. Trying to hide, destroy, remove the words we don't like,
|
|
it just buries away the honesty and the truth those files contain, directly
|
|
or indirectly.
|
|
<P>
|
|
Maybe some people shove the First Amendment too far away into the theoretical;
|
|
they think it applies to a particularly racy movie or whether you can get
|
|
Hustler at the 7-11. They forget it enters all our lives, all the time.
|
|
<P>
|
|
So they tried to bury what the pamphlet had to say.....
|
|
<P>
|
|
...let's take a little look at DEFCON as the pamphlet requests, shall we?
|
|
<P>
|
|
There's 4500 attendees, of which we can assume maybe 4,000 pay the admission
|
|
price. That's 4,000 x $50: $200,000. The speakers are unpaid, and must cover
|
|
hotel rooms, air travel, and whatever materials are required to put on their
|
|
show. (The Cult of the Dead Cow, for example, generally covers the cost of
|
|
renting their own lights, sound board, and props. This can run into the
|
|
thousands of dollars.) The Goons, the staff of DEFCON, is unpaid.
|
|
<P>
|
|
And then there's <A HREF="http://www.blackhat.com">BlackHat</A>. Held in
|
|
three different cities, the costs of attending are eye-opening: Over
|
|
<A HREF="http://www.blackhat.com/html/bh-usa-01/bh-usa-01-index.html">one
|
|
thousand dollars</A>! Scroll to the bottom of that link to see the sponsors.
|
|
Microsoft. PriceWaterhouseCoopers. This is not exactly the kind of
|
|
free flow of information you might expect. That's what DEFCON is for, they
|
|
say. But is it?
|
|
<P>
|
|
Jeff Moss (Dark Tangent) is a talented organizer; this is not something to
|
|
take lightly. Pulling off something like DEFCON requires a lot of experience
|
|
and many "best guesses" as to what will be needed. As time has gone on, he
|
|
has no doubt picked up skills as an organizer that few other people in his
|
|
line of work might have; this is why not everyone can run one of these
|
|
conventions successfully, year after year.
|
|
<P>
|
|
But if you look at the whole situation, you start to realize how truly
|
|
controlled, how
|
|
<A HREF="http://www.jinxhackwear.com/scripts/grpItems.asp?group=dc">buy-sell</A>, how
|
|
<A HREF="http://www.sheer.org/~curious/defcon/defcon/unsortedpicts-of-media-people/stuff6-001.jpg">media-oriented</A> and
|
|
<A HREF="http://www.netwiz.net/~spot/Adios_CPM/adios_cpm.html">look-at-me</A> the whole
|
|
situation has become. You might read
|
|
<A HREF="http://www.defcon.org/html/defcon-9-pre.html">words from the DEFCON
|
|
site that it's</A>
|
|
all about free flow of information, but it's not. Consider this:
|
|
<P>
|
|
The opening paragraph of the DEFCON information booklet <I>went out of its
|
|
way</I> to indicate that it was bigger than
|
|
<A HREF="http://www.h2k.net/">H2K</A>, the hacker convention held
|
|
on and off in New York City by
|
|
<A HREF="http://www.2600.com">2600 Magazine</A>.
|
|
It indicated it was bigger than
|
|
H2K was right now, and they would be 10,000 square feet bigger next year.
|
|
Why do this? Why attempt to indicate another convention wasn't worth going
|
|
to? Why especially do this when the other convention isn't being held in the
|
|
same city, is being held by folks who have been involved in the hacker
|
|
community for nearly 20 years, and make this your opening welcome to your
|
|
information booklet?
|
|
<P>
|
|
Maybe the money has become so big, any competition that looks like it might
|
|
come over the horizon and draw away dollars has to be addressed directly? Is
|
|
this a case where the most important thing about the entire process of
|
|
discussing your convention is to position it as the only choice, the assumed
|
|
leader in conventions? How long will it be before the
|
|
<A HREF="http://www.defcon.org/other-conventions.html">Other
|
|
Conventions Page</A> on the DEFCON site is no longer updated, or updated
|
|
with the information too late to actually attend?
|
|
<P>
|
|
These are ugly thoughts. But they rise from an ugly experience. An experience
|
|
I hope to never have again.
|
|
<P>
|
|
<I>- July 18, 2001</I>
|
|
</BODY>
|
|
</HTML>
|